It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
Do you have my quest - 'For Catacomber, Lord Zephar's Palace, travel to Roc's Roost Islands in the west and fetch her a Roc's egg to add to her rock collection.'
If you have more than one rope, drop all but one.
I just tested this and didn't have a problem.
I must have my Roc's egg before anyone else can have theirs. : ) I'm in Lord Zephar's Palace.